Subject: RE: Generator replacement
Author: murp-@aol.com
Date: Mar 8, 2001, 12:51 AM
Post ID: 1705773586
Tom and others,
Thanks for all the comments about installing a VW generator or
alternator.
The reason I want to go with a non-standard setup is because in my
Eldo restoration I am installing 1000 cc cylinders and a B-10 cam. This
cam was designed for the Tonti-frame bikes, and so the worm gear at the
end of the cam drives the distributor at twice the speed of an Eldo cam.
This means that I will have to go with a dual-point distributor setup
(which also means that I can use an electronic ignition system), but the
problem with that is that the distributor body will not clear the stock
generator. Because of this, I am looking for a setup which is smaller so
that I can mount the dual-point distributor. I would prefer an
alternator over a generator for the reasons already stated, but a
generator would be fine as long as it clears the distributor.
That said, I would very much like to see how that VW generator was
made to work.
Thanks,
Brian
'74 Eldo
'78 T3
Tom Bowes wrote:
Todd M. Nordwig wrote:
Well, Todd, there are many advantages to having an alternator rather than a generator in nearly any vehicle application, not just for loopframes. The advantages would be, in no particular order: 1) Rated output at lower RPM's than a comparable generator. 2) No commutator to wear out. 3) Reduced brush wear due to the fact that on a generator the armature (rotor) output is carried by the brushes. On an alternator the brushes ride on slip rings and carry the field current, which is much lower. 4) Modern alternators usually have the voltage regulator built in. 5) Higher amperage output from a similar package size. 6) Less "hash" and electrical noise. All that having been said, there is one HUGE disadvantage in trying to graft an alternator to a loopframe. It is nearly impossible to find one that will directly bolt in place of the generator. Therefore, installation of an alternator will probably adversely affect the looks of what is becoming a "classic" bike. Tom '70 Ambassador '82 V50-III Shelby Township, Michigan |